I haven't heard it yet, but I was disappointed in A&E.
I share your view Martin, on their debut album - at the time it was like nothing else, and still is just as unique and refreshing today.
I really loved the change of style with Black Cherry - such a contrast to their first album, and let's face it - how could you follow that up?! But the moody electronica really worked for me.
I was looking forward to a similar surprise and change in style with their third album, but when I first heard the awful "Ooh La La", I knew I would be let down. And I was. I like Supernature but only half as much, if that, as Black Cherry. It really did feel like selling out and pandering to the radio-friendly market.
I first heard Alison's voice on Peter Gabriel's OVO and I loved it, which led me to investigate their debut later that same year back in 2000. Sadly by the time of Supernature, I found her vocals either indechipherable or too heavily distorted and that glowing, sexy appeal that drew me to her, was gone - just like her eyebrows.
So with the new album I haven't bought it on face value, as I did Black Cherry. From what I've heard so far, it is a try before you buy affair.