I would recommend both Amarok and TBIII.
Here are the reviews that I have written for each album on the
Rate Your Music website:
AMAROKAmarok is a bizarre offering, with Mike Oldfield at his most experimental. All the tracks form one huge soundscape, with Mike playing every instrument or object he could lay his hands on. These include a chainsaw, shoes, a toothbrush and pair of wind-up toy teeth to name but a few. No samples here, and no computers – it's all done by hand. Anything that makes a noise is on this album.
Hidden between the various noises and unexpectedly loud bits, there is also some truly beautiful music – short but sweet. Certainly some of Mike's best guitar melodies. Sadly they don't last long enough before musically running off in random directions, ranging from African drumming and Zulu chanting, to flamenco guitar and tap dancing. There's also a welcome return of the Piltdown Man.
Amarok takes musical elements similar to parts of
Tubular Bells, Ommadawn and
QE2 and fuses them together into one hour-long piece, going back to Oldfield's original way of writing and recording – he even reunited with original
Tubular Bells producer, Tom Newman. When Richard Branson heard
Amarok for the first time, he thought it good enough to actually be
Tubular Bells II, although Oldfield thought otherwise, and rightly so.
Despite the unusual list of 'instruments' played,
Amarok is a very musical album, and after a few plays (and it can take a while to get used to), it becomes very addictive. It's one of those albums where you discover something new with each play, and with so many beautiful, melodic parts, it is a must for any true fan of Oldfield's music.
Finally,
Amarok comes with a health warning for those incapable of appreciating his work:
This record could be hazardous to the health of cloth-eared nincompoops. If you suffer from this condition, consult your Doctor immediately.Tubular Bells III Rather than another continuation of the original theme,
Tubular Bells III offers a refreshing, contemporary approach, with an upbeat, minimalistic variation of the classic melody.
The opening track "The Source of Secrets" and the closing medley "Secrets"/"Far Above the Clouds" work remarkably well, and the guitar-driven "Outcast" taking you back to the feel of the original album with a real energy. However the album's strongest piece by far is the stunning, epic finalé, "Far Above the Clouds". This track has to be Oldfield's most powerful and driving piece of music to date and the most adventurous use of the tubular bells. When that first huge bell thunders in, it sends a shiver down the spine. If anything "Far Above the Clouds" represents Mike Oldfield's musical zenith as far as Tubular Bells is concerned. The guitar solo is awe-inspiring, as the notes scream and cry, while one of the original album's most memorable basslines kicks in towards the end. A breathtaking and moving piece of music.
However, sandwiched in between these excellent pieces, is a mixed bag of styles, which includes flamenco and a full-vocal song, "Man in the Rain", based loosely on "Moonlight Shadow" and nice though it is, couldn't sound more out of place.
With fewer musical evolutions,
Tubular Bells III is a shorter, more conventionally structured album, and the mixture of styles don't work quite as well this time round. Although the music is very good, it just doesn't flow as well.
Overall,
Tubular Bells III isn't perhaps as tubular as it could have been, but even so it is an album worth checking out. I suspect the many who ridicule it, never got as far as the last two tracks.