Originally posted by Herbert the turbot:
Whilst I understand your annoyance at the "In The Glow" story resurfacing again, Rob, I'd just like to make a couple of points here. Firstly, it is on topic - this thread is about the forthcoming re-releases of John's first 3 solo albums, and we're discussing the unreleased tracks that are on them and speculating as to where they come from.
I'm sorry if I came across as being 'annoyed', 'cos that certainly wasn't my intention.
Instead I was more perplexed as to why everyone was more intent on wanting to discuss an album that doesn't exist as opposed to three albums that do. In the ensuing exchanges, which seem to have been centred around whether or not
In The Glow could be discussed - as opposed to actually discussing it - no-one appears to have picked up on the fact that there's an 'alternative version' of
A Long Time on the second disc of
The Golden Section ("what was it about this track which made John want to revisit it?") and that the 'extended mix' of
Endlessly (also on the second disc of
The Golden Section) has been marked as being
previously unreleased ("could this perhaps be a different version to the one which appeared on the
Endlessly 12 inch single?").
In short, I've got absolutely no problem with
In The Glow being discussed - the more discussion the better - so if there's someone out there who wants to start a thread, then please do so. But, I will say that the last time this issue was raised (some four years ago over on the
EV website), it managed to garner only eight responses.
Originally posted by Herbert the turbot:
However, for many Foxx fans, myself included, John was making the best music of his career between 1981 and 1983, so any unreleased tracks from that era, whether part of an abandoned album or not, represent the “Holy Grail” of John’s lost or unreleased material.
I'm a fan as well - I have been ever since I first heard
Metamatic and
Systems of Romance. I think that these releases are a really good balance of the
expected and the
unexpected. After all, would you really want a
predictable release from John - wasn't it that
edge that made everyone here a fan of his in the first place?
Rob